Foul Ball and Foul Play: Can the MLB’s CBA Keep Zack Gelof’s Lawsuit Out of Court?

In July, Sacramento Athletics utility player Zack Gelof made a sliding attempt to catch a foul ball at Comerica Park, the home of the Detroit Tigers.[2] Gelof’s knee struck a piece of exposed metal fencing, which cut into his leg and nearly severed a tendon.[3] Gelof’s injury sidelined him for around one month of the Major League Baseball (“MLB”) season.[4] On September 28, Gelof filed a lawsuit in Michigan state court against the Tigers, their parent company, and the public stadium authority, alleging negligence and premises liability.[5] Professional athletes rarely commence legal action against opposing teams especially when the injury occurs during gameplay.[6]
So, what happens next?
THE CBA AS A BACKSTOP
Under § 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act (“LMRA”), an injury claim must go through arbitration if resolving it is “substantially dependent” on interpreting a union contract such as MLB’s collective bargaining agreement (“CBA”).[7] The Tigers will probably rely on CBA Articles XIII and XI. Article XIII establishes a joint committee for “safe and healthful working conditions for players,” and provides a method for players to file grievances regarding safety issues.[8] Article XI specifies arbitration as the “exclusive remedy” for disputes over the CBA.[9]
The Tigers’ first move will likely be an attempt at removal to federal court on the theory that § 301 completely preempts Gelof’s state law claims.[10] Specifically, they would move for a finding that the dispute cannot be resolved without interpreting the CBA’s safety provisions, requiring resolution to occur through private arbitration.
THIRD TIME’s NOT THE CHARM
These kinds of arguments have failed teams in similar situations. In 2017, then-Yankees outfielder Dustin Fowler crashed into an unpadded electrical box during an away game against the White Sox.[11] Fowler sued the White Sox, who subsequently responded with an Article XIII argument.[12] A federal judge rejected the argument, holding that “Article XIII leaves no doubt that the clubs were in a vastly better position than the Committee to assess the safety of their own premises.”[13] In 2023, then-Brewers infielder Darin Ruf injured his knee on an unpadded tarp roller during an away game against the Reds.[14] The Reds presented the same argument as the White Sox.[15] The court rejected it, reasoning that MLB’s safety committee had no binding authority or supervisory role.[16]
PATRICK’S PLAYBOOK DOESN’T FIT
A related case involving the National Football League (“NFL”) produced a different result. Broncos linebacker Aaron Patrick tore his ACL after his cleat got caught in a sideline cable during a game hosted by the Chargers.[17] The NFL successfully removed the case to federal court, where the claims were dismissed so they could proceed through the NFL’s grievance process.[18] However, Patrick’s case was different from Gelof’s in two significant ways.
First, the relevant NFL CBA provision, Article 39, requires that “every stadium in which an NFL game is to be played must be in compliance with the Committee’s revised Mandatory Practices,” which cover out-of-bounds areas.[19] The Patrick court recognized that deciding the case required interpreting the specific Mandatory Practices.[20] MLB’s CBA has nothing comparable to the Mandatory Practices provision. Article XIII establishes that the safety committee “shall only have advisory authority” and does not mandate specific field-safety practices.[21] Attachment 66 only requires teams to add netting to protect fans.[22] No rule requires padding for walls or fences to protect the players. Without one, there is nothing for a court to interpret in connection with Gelof’s claim.
Second, the Patrick court applied California’s rule that there is no duty to protect athletes from risks “inherent” in their sport and considered the sideline injury to have arisen from such a risk.[23] Michigan law does not have such a carve-out. Michigan’s narrower inherent risk rule applies only to co-participants, not to those who control the premises.[24] Even an obvious hazard does not defeat a claim outright; it merely affects how fault is divided among the parties.[25] Michigan law offers the Tigers no escape.
PADDING THE NEXT CBA
If the Tigers do attempt removal, a judge will likely send the case back to state court, where it will probably end in a settlement between Gelof and the Tigers. After that, MLB and the players’ union may consider adding specific field-safety precautions to the next CBA to prevent future disputes like this one. The timing is right for a broader fix, with the current CBA expiring on December 1 and negotiations ongoing between the league and the players’ union.[26] It may be worthwhile for the parties to explore adopting binding standards, such as mandatory padding for walls, fences, and structures near the field of play. Both sides would benefit. Players would get literal protection before injuries instead of relying on the law after them. Clubs would be able to consistently rely on arbitration as a dispute resolution vehicle. MLB already protects its fans with netting. Its players deserve the same.
REFERENCES
[1] Neil Cornwall, The Boys of Summer (2019), https://flic.kr/p/2foVYYY.
[2] Athletics’ Zack Gelof Sues Tigers After Hitting Metal Fence, ESPN (Sept. 29, 2026), https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/50059756/athletics-zack-gelof-sues-tigers-hitting-metal-fence.
[3] Id.
[4] Id.
[5] Id.
[6] Brett Taylor, A Player Suing an Opposing Team for an Injury? That’s a Fascinating One, Bleacher Nation (Sept. 29, 2026), https://www.bleachernation.com/cubs/2026/09/29/a-player-suing-an-opposing-team-for-an-injury-thats-a-fascinating-one/.
[7] Allis-Chalmers Corp. v. Lueck, 471 U.S. 202, 220 (1985).
[8] 30 Major League Clubs & Major League Baseball Players Ass’n, 2022–2026 Basic Agreement art. XIII, § A(1), (4), at 55–56 (2022).
[9] Id. art. XI, at 40.
[10] 28 U.S.C. § 1441(a).
[11] Nico, Zack of All Trades Tries to Get One More Win: In Court, Athletics Nation (Oct. 2, 2026), https://www.athleticsnation.com/athletics-analysis/110355/zack-of-all-trades-tries-to-get-one-more-win-in-court.
[12] Fowler v. Ill. Sports Facilities Auth., 338 F. Supp. 3d 822, 824 (N.D. Ill. 2018).
[13] Id. at 827.
[14] Katrina Stebbins, Athletics Outfielder Zack Gelof Sues Tigers in Bizarre Early Twist to Detroit’s Offseason, Motor City Bengals (Sept. 29, 2026), https://motorcitybengals.com/athletics-outfielder-zack-gelof-sues-tigers-in-bizarre-early-twist-to-detroit-s-offseason.
[15] Ruf v. Cincinnati Reds, No. 1:25-CV-424, 2026 WL 179943, at *1 (S.D. Ohio Jan. 23, 2026).
[16] Id. at *10.
[17] Patrick v. Nat’l Football League, No. CV 23-1069-DMG (SHKx), 2023 WL 6162672, at *1 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 21, 2023).
[18] Id. at *7.
[19] Id. at *6.
[20] Id. at *7.
[21] 30 Major League Clubs & Major League Baseball Players Ass’n, supra note 8, art. XIII, § A(3), at 56.
[22] Id. attach. 66, at 403.
[23] Patrick, 2023 WL 6162672, at *5.
[24] Ritchie-Gamester v. City of Berkley, 597 N.W.2d 517, 525 (Mich. 1999).
[25] Kandil-Elsayed v. F & E Oil, Inc., 1 N.W.3d 44, 69 (Mich. 2023).
[26] Will There Be a Lockout? A Salary Cap? MLB’s Labor Battle Explained, ESPN (Nov. 3, 2026), https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/50370123/lockout-salary-cap-cba-labor-battle-faq.

Brody Pasieka '29, is a 1L at Villanova from Cream Ridge, NJ. He graduated from Washington and Lee University in 2026 with a B.S. in Business Administration, where he was a four-year member and senior captain of the baseball team.
Brody is a die-hard Phillies and Villanova Basketball fan. He enjoys exploring and writing about the intersection of sports and corporate law.




Comments